Ordered both colors because I couldn't decide which one I wanted. You can tell the excellent workmanship just by looking at the construction of the wallet, this is built to last a long time. Plenty of room for all of my credit cards (I have too many) and I noticed it even has a spot for an extra key, what a neat touch! There is also a little flap pocket that I assume is for coins, I can fit a couple quarters in there but if you carry a lot of coins you wouldn't be buying a minimalist wallet anyway. The pull-tab is very useful and I can retrieve cards very quickly. I am impressed by how sturdy the ID window slot is, the material is very thick and durable and the stitching is very strong. This is important to me because ID windows tend to be the 'Achilles heel' for wallets in my experience and are the first part to break. Don't think this ID window will break for a long time, if at all. The only thing I didn't like was that the brown color had a chemically smell for a couple days (I assume due to the dye) but it mostly just smelled like leather to me and dissipated quickly. The tan color didn't have the smell so if you are especially sensitive to smells you might want to go with that one, but if you leave the brown one out in the garage for a couple days the smell will disappear too. Also want to say that the customer service was very good, I had emailed them some questions before purchasing and they replied almost instantly with very detailed answers and were very friendly and helpful. Shipping was also very fast, overall very pleased with this purchase.